Our rating method
This grid applies to every score out of 10 on the site since 29/10/2026: each review shows the detail of its 5 criteria. For reviews published before that date, the criteria were set from our existing detailed assessments (formulation, published information, origin, price, delivery, customer service) converted to a score out of 10, and from public customer reviews recorded on our pages; they are refined at each update.
How we score brands
Every brand rated in our reviews and comparisons gets a score out of 10 based on five weighted criteria. The framework is the same for every rated brand, partner or not; the final score may however include an editorial assessment by LMC and differ from the average of the displayed criteria, in particular for partner brands. Some brands are commercial partners of LMC: the way they are highlighted (position in a comparison, “Partner brand” block, sponsored ranking page) may result from a commercial agreement. These partnerships are explained on our Transparency page.
Why these weightings
Formulation carries the most weight (35%) because it is what defines a food supplement: what it actually contains, in what quantity, and whether the manufacturer proves it. It is also the most discriminating criterion on the market, because many brands never publish their dosages.
Proven quality (20%) is our objective stand-in for “effectiveness”, which European regulations do not allow us to promise: since we cannot measure effects, we measure the evidence, meaning certifications, lab analyses and traceability.
Price (20%) only means something once it is brought back to the dose: comparing a 100 g pouch and a 240 g pouch on headline price tells you nothing. And because we are funded in part by affiliate commissions, we structurally refuse to score promotions: a discount code can never improve a rating.
Reviews (15%) reflect real satisfaction, but they depend on how many a brand has collected and how long it has been trading: a meaningful weight, never a dominant one. Guarantees and service (10%) count towards the buying experience, but stay secondary to the product itself.
What this framework deliberately does not score: packaging, branding, how broad the range is, or the quality of the online shop. A comparison that rewards marketing is no longer comparing products.
The scale for each criterion (0 to 10)
Formulation & verifiable dosages (35%)
- 10: every individual dosage published AND confirmed by lab analyses you can access; actives at the levels used in published studies; form specified (extract, ratio, standardisation).
- 8 to 9: every individual dosage published, at studied levels, form documented, but no accessible analytical confirmation.
- 6 to 7: most dosages published, or a total active content given with partial detail.
- 3 to 5: partial dosages, “proprietary blend”, or percentages with no milligrams.
- 0 to 2: no usable dosage information.
A brand is scored on what it publishes: we never extrapolate, and we display “Not disclosed”. If it publishes its dosages or its analyses later, its score is recalculated at the next update, in either direction.
Proven quality & traceability (20%)
- 9 to 10: batch analyses published or accessible (named laboratory, dated batches) plus documented manufacturing; the 10 comes with a verifiable certification (organic, GMP and so on).
- 6 to 8: partial evidence, such as a named independent laboratory with no accessible analyses, a certification on its own, or documented traceability without analyses.
- 3 to 5: quality claims with no supporting document available.
- 0 to 2: no evidence at all, or inconsistencies between the claims and the documents.
Price per dose (20%)
Scored relative to the category panel, on standard public prices at the date recorded: 9 to 10 for the best quarter of the panel in €/dose (and €/mg of active where it can be calculated), 6 to 8 for the middle half, 3 to 5 for the bottom quarter, 0 to 2 when the gap exceeds twice the median. The full calculation is shown in every comparison.
Customer reviews (15%)
Starting point: the third-party platform rating, capped by volume: under 50 reviews, capped at 6; 50 to 500 reviews, capped at 8; over 500 reviews, capped at 10. Reviews hosted on the brand’s own site count for two thirds of their value. The source and the date recorded are shown on every profile.
Guarantees & service (10%)
- 9 to 10: a money-back guarantee of 30 days or more, valid on opened products; fast delivery and clear terms; customer service you can reach, with published opening hours.
- 5 to 8: the statutory right of withdrawal applied properly, terms published and no hidden fees.
- 0 to 4: restrictive terms (unopened products only, fees deducted), or no information published at all.
Our data rules
- Sources: manufacturers’ product pages and official information, plus public review platforms. Every profile and every comparison shows the date it was last updated.
- Missing data: we write “Not disclosed”. Never an estimate, never an extrapolation. When no public customer review could be recorded, the Consumer reviews criterion is excluded from the calculation and the weights of the other criteria are scaled back to 100%.
- One score per product: in our reviews and comparisons, a brand’s score out of 10 is the same everywhere it appears. Sponsored ranking pages may display a score out of 100 specific to that page.
- Labels: “Best choice” and “Best value” are based on the framework scores. The first place in a comparison may, however, be given to a partner brand under a commercial agreement (see Transparency).
- Right to correction: any brand can report inaccurate data to hello@le-meilleur-complement.fr. We correct it after checking against its official documents and update the date on the profile.
What the score is not
The score does not measure the physiological effectiveness of a product: food supplements are not medicines, and we do not run clinical trials. It measures transparency, the density and the evidence behind the formula, the real price and the verifiable commitments of each brand, in other words everything a consumer can objectively compare before buying.
Transparency and commercial interests
LMC has economic interests with some of the brands featured here, including Mush N Go, Primal Supplements and Arrow.
In practice: the site is funded by affiliate commissions paid by brands when you buy through our links (at no extra cost to you), by commercial partnerships and by sponsored content. A notice at the top of reviews, promo code pages and comparisons reminds you of these ties.
These economic ties may influence how a brand is highlighted (position, featured blocks, sponsored pages). They do not change the factual information we publish about it: composition, dosages, prices and terms are taken from its official documents, according to the framework above.

LMC partner brand 💛
LMC partner: Mush n Go’s Brainstoorm mushroom coffee, the highest-dosed in our comparison.
.avif)

pick



